New Sticky Note

The new user interface is in preview!

Want to check it out? Click here! (If you don't like it, you can still switch back)

League Forums

Main - League News/General Discussion

Re: It makes you think…

By martinwarnett
9/15/2025 1:38 am
hkpman7180 wrote:
setherick wrote:
I brought up the idea of a trade committee in the past and no one seemed that interested.

I'm too busy to police trades that don't drastically change the talent calculus of a team, which usually means top first round picks.

There have been a lot of bad trades, but nothing to the point of egregiously trading away top 10 picks year after year for veterans at the end of their career. Even Martin trade of the SS as bad as it was will likely not set back Tennessee. The problem with that trade is the SS only has one position and can't flex to CB to finish his career.



One missed out fact most of my so called borderline trades has associated correction trade too……

Anyway my goal was never to reverse so will move on knowing it’s ok to have borderline trades has as long as it’s 2nd rd picks


One missed out fact is all of your correction trades occurred once called out.


Re: It makes you think…

By hkpman7180
9/15/2025 11:33 pm
martinwarnett wrote:
hkpman7180 wrote:
setherick wrote:
I brought up the idea of a trade committee in the past and no one seemed that interested.

I'm too busy to police trades that don't drastically change the talent calculus of a team, which usually means top first round picks.

There have been a lot of bad trades, but nothing to the point of egregiously trading away top 10 picks year after year for veterans at the end of their career. Even Martin trade of the SS as bad as it was will likely not set back Tennessee. The problem with that trade is the SS only has one position and can't flex to CB to finish his career.



One missed out fact most of my so called borderline trades has associated correction trade too……

Anyway my goal was never to reverse so will move on knowing it’s ok to have borderline trades has as long as it’s 2nd rd picks


One missed out fact is all of your correction trades occurred once called out.




Well even once called out Bucs corrected it weather it was required or not …..but am yet to see Lions even remotely trying
Last edited at 9/15/2025 11:37 pm

Re: It makes you think…

By martinwarnett
9/16/2025 5:40 am
hkpman7180 wrote:
martinwarnett wrote:
hkpman7180 wrote:
setherick wrote:
I brought up the idea of a trade committee in the past and no one seemed that interested.

I'm too busy to police trades that don't drastically change the talent calculus of a team, which usually means top first round picks.

There have been a lot of bad trades, but nothing to the point of egregiously trading away top 10 picks year after year for veterans at the end of their career. Even Martin trade of the SS as bad as it was will likely not set back Tennessee. The problem with that trade is the SS only has one position and can't flex to CB to finish his career.



One missed out fact most of my so called borderline trades has associated correction trade too……

Anyway my goal was never to reverse so will move on knowing it’s ok to have borderline trades has as long as it’s 2nd rd picks


One missed out fact is all of your correction trades occurred once called out.




Well even once called out Bucs corrected it weather it was required or not …..but am yet to see Lions even remotely trying


Might want to go for an eye test, mate, since I said Tennessee rejected any correction.

And lookee here...

https://nfl.myfootballnow.com/trade/12316

Re: It makes you think…

By hkpman7180
9/16/2025 6:47 am
If you try to reverse trade you did not needed titans just ask commish he can ….

Re: It makes you think…

By martinwarnett
9/16/2025 8:19 am
Except my way, with private messages sent, educates the other player.

I've made steps to amend - which you claimed I hadn't. Those were rejected by the Tennessee owner, who was bemused by my offer.

I've made that offer. It was rejected.

Tennessee want the player, have the player, I'm happy for them to have the player. I offered them a trade to balance up a bit more. They rejected.

If Seth can enforce the trade I referred you to, then great.

I'm not going to be lectured by you, mate.
Last edited at 9/16/2025 8:20 am

Re: It makes you think…

By setherick - League Admin
9/16/2025 8:40 am
Locking this thread. I gave a definitive response to why I've criticized some trades and not others. Unless a trade will likely break a team in the future (e.g. constantly swapping 1st round picks) then bad trades are just bad trades. We can discuss how they are bad, but we can also move on.